United States
Ohio
Conneaut
Conneaut Pizza & Sub Shop

Conneaut Pizza & Sub Shop

3.7 (210 reviews )

Pizza restaurant

No-contact delivery

Delivery

Takeout

Dine-in

About Conneaut Pizza & Sub Shop

Located at 223 Broad St in Conneaut, OH, Conneaut Pizza & Sub Shop has carved out a cherished place in the hearts of locals and visitors alike. Renowned for its legendary stromboli—maintaining the same recipe for over 40 years—this restaurant offers a delightful menu filled with pizzas, subs, and mouthwatering wings. Customers frequently praise the generous portions, fast service, and friendly staff, making for a welcoming dining experience. As a food reviewer, I find the food consistently satisfying, with standout flavors that transport you to comfort territory. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in the flavors that keep patrons returning!

Read reviews

View Menu

Reviews (210) 3.7

Tawnya Armstrong

Jun 16,2025

Order stromboli & 2 spaghetti dinners to eat in with 3 subs to go & cheesecakes. We was very satisfied with it all. Just like i remember. Good friendly service also. Will come back again on our next trip back up here
Melanie

May 26,2025

Same Stromboli recipe for over 40 years. Still as Great as the 1st one we bought. Employees are friendly. Clean Priced fair. Excellent!
Chris m

May 23,2025

Best stromboli and pizzas I've EVER had across the US. Wow! We bought several and traveled with them all the way back to Florida they were so outstanding. Staff is also friendly. My only regret is that we don't have this gem closer to home.
Saxon Kubiak

May 8,2025

Love the wings and stromboli. Also had the super sub a bunch of times ...
Robert Grantz

May 5,2025

I order delivery quite often and I am never disappointed. They are always earlier than expected... The food is always hot and good.
Ronna Bowyer

Apr 25,2025

Service was fast and pleasant. The food was all right, but nothing largely impressive. For a local dive of a spot, this place is pretty good. Building front is hard to spot from the road, so keep your eyes peeled. Great portions for the price. We enjoyed our visit and will most likely be back.
Erin Woolslayer

Apr 16,2025

Ordered takeout. Stromboli and Burgers. Great food, fast service. I'm a very picky eater... Will order again :)
M N

Mar 28,2025

The biggest and best stromboli for your money. It's always cooked perfectly and fully loaded with any toppings you request. Great tasting marinara sauce on the side, add a salad and it makes a excellent meal. Always had fast friendly service with a smile. Keep doing what you do. Thank you.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are some popular dishes at Conneaut Pizza & Sub Shop?

The stromboli and pizzas are highly praised by customers, with many considering them the best they've ever had!
Do I need to make a reservation to dine here?

No reservations are required; the restaurant accommodates walk-ins for both dine-in and takeout orders.
What dining options are available at the restaurant?

You can enjoy a meal in-house, take food to go, or opt for no-contact delivery.
What is the atmosphere like at Conneaut Pizza & Sub Shop?

The restaurant has a casual and cozy vibe, making it a great spot for groups or a quiet meal solo.
Is there parking available for customers?

Yes, there’s both a free parking lot and free street parking available for guests.